11/24/2023 0 Comments Funny quotes about decisions![]() ![]() “The Court’s next bit of interpretive jiggery-pokery involves other parts of the Act that purportedly presuppose the availability of tax credits on both federal and state Exchanges.” Even if it were true that the term ‘such Exchange’ … implies that federal and state Exchanges are the same in general, the term ‘established by the State’ … makes plain that they differ when it comes to tax credits in particular,” he said. “The Court’s argument also overlooks the rudimentary principle that a specific provision governs a general one. In the same case, Scalia argued that the interpretation of “such” in a particular phrase in the Obamacare legislation falsely claims that the federal and state exchanges are the same. “Otherwise, the Court says, there would be no qualified individuals on federal Exchanges, contradicting (for example) the provision requiring every Exchange to take the ‘interests of qualified individuals’ into account when selecting health plans.Pure applesauce.” “The Court claims that the Act must equate federal and state establishment of Exchanges when it defines a qualified individual as someone who (among other things) lives in the ‘State that established the Exchange’,” Scalia wrote. In his dissenting opinion on the Obamacare case, Scalia assessed one element of the majority’s opinion to be “pure applesauce” - Justice Stephen Breyer used a similar phrase in 2007 in his dissenting view: sheer applesauce. Here are 11 of his most memorable comments (in no particular order): ![]() After three decades on the highest court in the land, the conservative justice will also be remembered for his sometimes ineffable remarks. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |